Good question! Few Important Things For Sports Memorabilia Fans. The minus sign omits the results including the word after it and be sure to make sure you clear the box that states search 'title and description' because many legitimate dealers state that they do not sell reprints in their item descriptions and this search would then exclude them from the results as well. What is a 'White Sheet' autograph and how to avoid purchasing one. Then 21st get How to buy authentic autographs on eBay by World of Autographs. Additionally, an inexpensive Buy-It-Now price shows the dealer has no confidence (or simply knows it is not authentic) in the autograph he/she is selling and is often a sure sign it is a forgery! 0 Likes, Hi everyone,Need your help with this seller. But I have seen some recently certed BAS items that were not correct. Also, if the seller is adamantly opposed to 3rd party certification and even attempts to discredit these companies I again suggest you move along and just forget that seller. The forgers seem to like using some weird paint pen colors (especially on multiple signed forgeries). Should I ever trust eBay for celebrity autographs. The content you are looking for has been archived. You know your stuff. Many buyers don't learn an item is fake until they send it in to be authenticated or until someone experienced in autograph collecting and familiar with sports memorabilia informs them. Banned sellers/COAs list should be a mile long. Terms of Service. While I believe 95% of what was said and stated, there is still 5% of me thinking that several of these one offs or rare signatures could be real. a guide to buy authentic autographs and avoiding the fake autographs on ebay. Please Take A Look At This Seller's Sold Autographs, Steve Vai - Where The Wild Things Are DVD. It has come to our attention that some novice autograph buyers determine if they can trust that a sellers items are authentic based solely on their feedback score. Some bogus dealers even trick customers by providing a Certificate of Authenticity (usually from their own company) and a 100% satisfaction guarantee. Simple as that. If theyre not the first owner, they should be able to help you trace its origins. It will be dramatic! A now defunct company in Las Vegas used to do this. [CLICKABLE IMAGE] Famous British composer Benjamin Britten (1913-1976) shown at his private residence "The Red House" -photograph signed by him and dated in 1969. Great read Kevin! Ebay sellers with fake or questionable items for sale. I have ZERO interest in it, but I want the other items. Anyone else have the problem where a sellar stole $200, ebay won't help For full details, read our policy below. Appreciate. As I have mentioned before, these companies are not perfect. Copyright 1995-2023 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the current selection. Tweet Any improvement by ebayis most welcome, butitcould do a lot more with its resources. This is how we search anytime autographs are involved. I have been trying to apply Spendable Funds to a purchase; however, the The seller is an identifiable business or person. Many sellers of forgeries have perfect feedback. There is absolutely NO REASON for private auctions other than to hide something nefarious. An eBay Trust & Safety director once told me that stopping forgers on their site is akin to having a garden hose and they have to use it to put out a raging forest fire. It seems like he has taken an awful lot of business away from PSA. Buy a few books on autograph authentication. They also benefit sellers by helping to increase the value of their autographed items. 1. As someone who has written a book and many articles about the case over the years, I have a copy of the information that was released at that time. Thilak Siva BSc(Hons),LLM,MBA,MRICS,PMP,MCIArb,MAIQS, Eddie DeAngelis ~ Founder and CEO QualiFi, LLC "Our Vibe Attracts our Tribe". These third parties may use known authentic autograph examples to determine if these items are genuine or "likely not genuine." Regardless of whether youre an experienced autograph collector or simply a casual buyer looking for an autograph as a gift, you need to consider if the sellers are reputable, honest autograph dealers. January 30, 2009 By Rich Mueller. How the heck is Stephen Rocchi and his Guaranteed Forensic Authenticators (GFA) group not on the banned list!!!! Check their inventory. We may have to remove a listing if it violates our policiesor ifthe rights owner asksus to. Do your homework and research to determine it's a legit signature. This is the first list of names. But it shouldnt be the same case with similar items that were sold. The FBI's Operation Bullpen sting in the late . Ebay takes care of bidder privacy already. I'm no fan of TPAs, but that guy knows how to market himself. The current list of eBay approved autograph authenticators: James Spence Authentication PSA/DNA Beckett (BAS) SGC Authentic If the autograph authentication company you are thinking of utilizing is not on this list you should ask yourself why. They are not always the best examples of the autographs, as they rarely have any quotes extras on them, and often they are not as neatly signed, but at least you know they will be real. By signing up here, you are agreeing to receive periodic email updates, news and special promotional offers from Piece of the Past. One example of this would be a Harrison Ford autograph. Red flags include if the autographs are shown in small thumbnails only, which you cant magnify, or if they are in frames with big mats and decoration, where you can see the whole picture but can't truly see the autographs. I would not! A seller should stand behind what they sell. Kevin Nelson Updated: Dec 5, 2019 Original: Selling Fake Autographs? (310) 909-8722. (DoggyT-79 )Continue, Started by Daniel Alayof Aug 21, 2019. How can i find good seller. Important note about 3rd party authenticators by World of Autographs. In addition, click on the sellers ID top right next to their feedback and that will also tell you which county they are in. Feel free to contact Piece of the Past, one of the most trusted autograph dealers in the U.S., at (951) 258-4968. Because they want to get their fake autographed item sold as quickly as possible with the least amount of exposure to eBay's Trust & Safety agents, EMR members and other 'in the know collectors' they list the item for 1 or 3 days. 0 Likes, by Marvin Gee They are not selling under a nickname, such as those used on eBay. Getting a shot of a celebrity signing the exact item is a nightmare. We buy entire collections and not just the cream of the crop. Auto-suggest helps you quickly narrow down your search results by suggesting possible matches as you type. These guys help you sell your item on eBay,some unscrupulous forgers are using these outlets to sell their fake goods. If the autograph dealers dont have a website, the seller is not a professional dealer. Ransom E. Olds was an early automotive pioneer. While these items are very nice, they are one of the most difficult items to complete and very commonly faked. It is hard to find consistency in the pricing of items that are unsold and still being offered on the internet. Last reply by gaz Mar 10, 2022. Do you have an autograph collection to sell? Be sure to ask every seller you purchase from if you can have their office phone number, office address and website in case you need to contact them in the future. No Ebay Bucks for Q2 2023 so far? We hope the above lists will help you in evaluating your autograph purchases. Ebay does not police sellers very well and as a result forgers are all over eBay. Free shipping for many products! This button displays the currently selected search type. Started by KaiMi. Don't know who their guy is for that but they should stick to sports. CLAIMED. We honor our promise. I'll probably have to eat my purchase, but here goes. Some of the most popular categories of autograph subjects are presidents, military soldiers, athletes, movie stars, artists, social and religious leaders, scientists, astronauts, and authors.. Feedback is really only a place to find out if the seller keeps their promises regarding item descriptions, shipping speed and customer service. Be sure to include the following information in your listing: COAs and LOAs let buyers know that the signature is "likely genuine." That means collectors who bought signed material from these firms need to know that the items they own might be fake, and the documents that supposedly authenticated them could be, too. Remember, high positive feedback numbers only prove a seller has fulfilled their obligations to the seller (and this is important for sure). Please check your browser settings or contact your system administrator. Privacy Policy. Autograph collecting is the practice of collecting autographs of famous persons. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. The Before you even talk or contact autograph dealers online, do a background search first. 0 Likes, Hi everybody,I found two sellers in eBay I would appreciate your opinions about. Unauthorized reprints of trading cards that have had authorized reproductions created, such as unauthorized reprints of the: 1979 Wayne Gretzky rookie card reproduction, 1986 Mario Lemieux rookie card reproduction, 1986 Michael Jordan rookie card reproduction. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Rate Freight, Delivery: Varies but no EDD range given. The worst place to try and educate yourself on authentic autographs would be eBay. I had more info here but was threatened with legal action when I told the truth about each authenticator. However, most of. About us: (Starstruck Autographs Limited) With more than 20 years experience in the autograph industry 'Starstruck Autographs' have expanded from what was once a hobby into a full-time business. card-vault Adventurer (427feedbacks) View listings Options Mark as New Bookmark Subscribe Mute Subscribe to RSS Feed Permalink Print Email to a Friend Report Inappropriate Content 01-11-201712:43 PM So, this is a topic I have wanted to post on here. This isn't proof positive but it will help you gather some information that can help steer you in the right direction. Plus, now the seller knows that you have no idea what you are doing and will enjoy taking advantage of such an easy target. Thanks ! Don't just accept what the item location says. and our Someone selling autographs next to used shoes or vintage furniture is unlikely to be a professional autograph dealer. Obviously Beckett got on the list because of Steve Grad. Sure Read our full policy Some collectors may specialize in specific fields (such as Nobel Prize winners) or general topics (military leaders . Be sure to ask every seller you purchase a signed photo from if it is a white sheet or in ink-jet printed photo. Good, experienced, and professional dealers tend to rely on their own opinion about what is authentic, they do not want to use the opinions of others all the time in order to run their business. We investigate concerns from our members in regard to autographs, COAs, LOAs, and trading cards. Your email address will not be published. Make sure the dealer has a return policy that they will stand behind. Johns says the blog was created to help prevent unsuspecting customers from buying fake autographs. Autographs are commonly sold with Certificates of Authenticity (COA) or letters of authenticity (LOAs). JUST IN CASE, LET ME REMIND YOU, NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER DO IT. One example of this would be a Harrison Ford autograph. Ebay is correct that it is up to the seller to show the cards or not. Also watch out for items signed in odd colors. I am not suggesting that these 3rd party autograph certification companies are all awesome and perfect but just that it seems those most strongly opposed often deal in bad material. BAS, PSA/DNA and GA will check any eBay auction and now you can send them most any item for sale anywhere and give you their opinion on the possible authenticity of the item. We are ar AFTAL approved dealer. I see someone asked about pakratsrus. Autograph Value - How to Find It and Other Questions. Operation Bullpen: Authenticators and Autograph Sellers to Watch for Authenticators and sellers targeted by the FBI for forgeries and frauds are still finding their way onto online marketplace sites, including eBay. haslett, CA. Home of guaranteed authentic, autographed photos specializing in 8x10 pictures, signed rock collectibles & authentic sports memorabilia. This can be done long before you bid and they usually respond in 24-48 hours. However, the top pick is the gorgeous Oldsmobile Toronado. place a temporary hold on funds for new or infrequent sellers, until I definitely walk away, but it's infuriating that nothing will be done to stop him. 0 Comments There are a few exceptions to this rule- BAS, GA, JSA and PSA/DNA COAs' provide proof that the item is most likely genuine. But theyre not on eBays forbidden list. A clear photo of the COA or LOA, as well as the name of the person or company issuing the certificate, A clear photo of the actual autographed item, Information about the COA or LOA, including the name of the person or company issuing the certificate, Refund policy, in case a reputable dealer informs us or the buyer that the item is "likely not authentic", Authentic and authorized pre-printed autographs or autographed items should generally be listed in the Autographs-Reprints category. A dialog will open as you type your search terms. Remember to always exercise caution and take your time when buying autographs; there is no need to rush into any sale. To address this going forward, as of 2019, we have changed our COA policy to include fully illustrated letters of authenticity on ANY item we sell over $300.00 with matching tamper-proof holograms on the letter and item. For full details, read our policy below. No website. This is an example of a COA used by Round Five from FBI files, a New Jersey company run by ex-heavyweight boxer Chuck Wepner. Although the FBI put more 60 people in jail a few years ago for dealing and distributing fake autographs, the dealers who sold on eBay all had excellent feedback records. Round Five is among the memorabilia firms to appear on a comprehensive list released by the FBI of all organizations involved in its years-long Operation Bullpen investigation related to forged memorabilia. and Other Burning Autograph Questions Posted on March 19, 2021, Where to Sell Autographs: Things to Keep an Eye On Posted on April 07, 2021, Where to Buy Authentic Autographs Posted on February 19, 2021, Glossary of Autograph Terms Posted on December 10, 2020, Autograph Authentication: Where to Get Autographs Authenticatedand More Posted on March 12, 2021, Autograph Value - How to Find It and Other Autograph Worth Questions Posted on May 07, 2021, Old Photographs: The Evolution of Photographic Formats Posted on April 15, 2021, What Are the Factors that Determine Autograph Values? New episodes weekly! They seem to have an unlimited supply of extremely rare autographed items. Below we list some of the key things you need to know in order to evaluate who you are buying from. These guidelines will help you successfully sell these types of items on our website. Start by doing a Google search for the seller's name along with the word "Scam" "Fake Autographs" "Forgeries", etc. If you are going to rely on external authenticators, make sure you select really good ones (see our article) and that they have expertise in the area or category of your desired autograph (film, sports, politics, music, etc.). Authentic autographs do not sell for $9.99 (obviously a dealer might throw some autographs up at that price once in awhile and there is one well known dealer that does this every week but that is the exception). Visit Seller Help - opens in new window or tab to find details of any policy issues with your account or listings, and get the information you need to quickly resolve them. For more information, please see our Kelly Johns| over the years. Most collectors never use them (private signings are an exception of course and when the situation is low key). You can get an idea for the true value for most pieces by doing some research. How do I find an order with an order number? "At one point, I had about 18,000 Ali . REMEMBER: ANYBODY CAN SIGN UP FOR EBAY/A WEBSITE/ IOFFER/ EBID/ BONANZA, AMAZON & ETC, BUY SOME 8X10 PHOTOS, SCRIBBLE SOME WORDS AND THEY ARE INSTANTLY AN AUTOGRAPH SELLER. Check out the lists of who's not allowed on eBay and other who should be on the list. Government, transit or shipping company property is not allowed. Item due April 26, after several delays. That's a shame when the authenticity is in question, I'm sure people will get screwed and not even know it. The seller may have good reasons for this, a personal opinion that is negative about a service should not be a reason to earn the title of fake seller. Any experiences? Kindly respond. Sellers with lots of these autographs will usually use the excuse that he/she was very old or in a rush when this was signed. We applaud any group who furthers this hobby and the UACC, PADA, RACC and AFTAL are doing their part and no blatant forger will be able to join their ranks. Autograph Live: How to use our Musician-Direct Autograph Sales Forum. Many newer and inexperienced in-person autograph collectors are resorting to what are called White Sheets in order to obtain autographs when they are not prepared, simply do not know what they are doing, are cheap, just too lazy, or simply do not care about their customers. However, authentic autographs are just not available in the quantities you see on eBay/ the web. Not showing autographs properly is one of the biggest indicators that there is something they are hiding. EVER!!! To further help you, we list below some of the factors that are not, in our opinion, reasons for a dealer to be considered dishonest or a fake autograph seller. Automotive (eBay Motors) Books Business & Industrial Cameras & Photo Clothing, Shoes & Accessories Coins & Paper Money Collectibles Computers, Tablets & Networking Consumer Electronics Crafts Dolls & Bears Entertainment Memorabilla Gift Cards & Coupons Health & Beauty Home & Garden Jewelry Music Pottery & Glass Specialty Services Sporting Goods Their names are: The COA of Reel Memories. I bet over the past 3 years alone they have sold 200 Hal Smith a.k.a. Any autograph before 1960 will be in pencil or pen. If they dont, then this is a huge red flag, and it is probably better not to buy. 0 Likes, 2023 Created by Steve Cyrkin, Admin. I just like to know why I have not received any opportunities to earn Report an Issue | Many of these short duration items, if authentic, would be of very high value yet they list them for an opening bid of sometimes as low as $.99. That means more than 6,600 of the 10,000 signatures PSA-DNA sampled were forgeries. It makes it stops your mind from 'reading' the signature and makes it easier to spot the differences. While a real, reputable autograph dealer may fail in 1 or 2 of the above points, a fake one will fail in more. While it is impossible to definitively estimate the percentage of forged memorabilia, industry experts concede that more than half of the most sought-after athletes and celebrities autographed memorabilia is forged, according to the FBIs online summary of its Operation Bullpen investigation. California State residents must add 9% sales tax. How to recognize Preprint Autographs by World of Autographs. Fox 19 (Cincinnati, OH) news story on fake autograph sold at charity auctions. Great article, and thanks for your insight. Purchasing autographs on the internet is definitely not recommended for the novice collector as you will most certainly purchase fake autographs (Unless you buy from us or a very small handful of other trusted dealers and in-person collectors.). If they are the first owner, they should be able to tell you the exact events that helped them acquire the autograph from the celebrity. Assistant Vice President Collections & Reporting CIT. I think it's stolen. In my opinion the only time a proof photo can be implicitly trusted is when the seller has a photo of the celebrity signing the EXACT item listed for sale. There can be many Non-PSA/DNA, Beckett, JSA of these players floating around. An authorized reproduction means a company has acquired the rights to accurately reproduce the original card, 1933 Babe Ruth (Goudey #53, #80, #144, and #181), 1966-1967 Bobby Orr rookie card (Topps #35), 1979-1980 Wayne Gretzky rookie card (O-Pee-Chee and Topps #18), 1986-1987 Michael Jordan rookie card (Fleer #57). As part of this effort, we are going to for deserving sellers. They loath autograph authentication companies. Posted on June 04, 2021, Autograph CoA: Certificate of Authenticity? If you do, you will purchase a forgery! This service usually has a reasonable cost. eBays Not Allowed list Businesses and individuals on eBays Not Allowed list are regarded as not reputable; their COAs and LOAs cannot be used to certify material offered on the site. The industry's leading autograph authenticator, PSA-DNA, claims that only 33 percent of more than 10,000 Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan autographs it scrutinized were real. Celebs often provide signed photos to them (sometimes in bulk) to help raise funds. From the Braves autographs they have, they appear legit to me, Rhonda. Privacy Policy | (Blog Article), - Where to Sell Autographs: Things to Keep an Eye On (Blog Article), -Glossary of Autograph Terms (Blog Article), - Autograph Collecting 101: A Beginners Guide (Blog Article), - Autograph CoA: Facts You Should Know (Blog Article), - Facsimile Autograph: How to Detect Printed Signatures (Blog Article), -Ten Things that Make a Signed Photo Perfect (Blog Article), How to Know When an Autograph is Authentic Posted on March 26, 2021, What does Autograph Mean? I think that would hold the same in many cities like signed Allen Iverson card or hat in Philly area, or a Dan Marino football in Miami etc. Last reply by gaz Mar 10, 2022. Sometimes I take a gamble but more often than not I walk away. Memorabilia. No CoA (Certificate of Authenticity) or even invoice when you request. The FBI believes the trafficking ring targeted in Operation Bullpen created and sold $100 million of forged memorabilia to retailers and consumers in nearly every state, according to FBI documents. Many sellers of fake cast/band signed items would have you believe that celebrities are just lining up all day to sign their items but it simply is not true. Autographs are not obtained that way and you would be surprised how many agents and managers become angered when you ask for an autograph in-person. But there were plenty of other authenticators besides J. DiMaggio who came under investigation by the FBI. Latest Activity: Apr 5, 2022, MySpace !function(d,s,id){var js,fjs=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];if(!d.getElementById(id)){js=d.createElement(s);js.id=id;js.src="//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js";fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js,fjs);}}(document,"script","twitter-wjs"); If you do not know who to trust you will buy a forgery. Something went wrong. Access the document and edit content using the Tools list. Analyze the autograph to make sure that it is not a preprint (photos, books and letters only). 0 Likes, I sent a note asking about the authenticity of a Robin Williams photo and was immediately blocked by this seller. If they are a registered on eBay as a business seller, then they will have their full business address at the bottom of the page. You can chat with other members about anything to do with buying on eBay. of shoes and paid with my paypal. If the autographs sell for $50 or $100 or lower than their general value, you'd best look for other autograph dealers online. COAs and LOAs can offer assurance that an autograph is genuine, but you need to be sure the authenticator is reputable. I work with I cannot place a bid or cannot make an offer, when I click on the make An honest seller will have nothing to hide andwill not get defensive and happily answer your questions. However, unless you really know how to spot an authentic signature it would be safer to purchase one that has been examined and certified authentic. 0 Comments The collector has the celebrity sign the blank sheet of ink-jet paper (usually in a blue Sharpie as most other colors do not work well), then later, once they are home, they load the paper into their ink-jet printer and print an image of their choice onto the sheet and over the autograph. He is registered dealer at UACC and AFTAL and therefore seems to be good. Inventory consistency. Several promoters I follow who have used PSA for decades at their public and private signing have all moved to Beckett. Currency Exchange Fee. I would appreciate your opinion about this seller and the autographs that he sold.Continue. Three years later, in 2005, the FBI announced the results of all their memorabilia investigations and released a comprehensive list of all the Operation Bullpen-involved organizations it had busted. Our policy on the sale of autographs and autographed items provides guidance to keep all of our members safe when buying or selling on eBay. These collectors are not fans nor do they care about autographs at all. The industry's leading autograph authenticator, PSA-DNA, claims that only 33 percent of more than 10,000 Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan autographs it scrutinized were real. There are many autographs that just dont exist in any real quantities. Default; Distance; Rating; Name (A - Z) View all businesses that are OPEN 24 Hours. I have found a few of these sellers that use 3rd party picture hosting services and as soon as you pay they pull down the photo of the item your won. Retired Professor of Radiography & Radiation Therapy. 0 Likes, Hello again,anybody familiar with eBay seller usjpskipper?Here is the link:Continue, Started by Shawn K. Last reply by Shawn K Nov 14, 2021.