The grievance that McDonough submitted to Bidwill's attorney last week and Goodell on Tuesday alleged that "Bidwill's widespread workplace misconduct is significantly worse than the misbehavior of former crosstown Phoenix Suns owner Robert Sarver," whom the NBA suspended one year and fined $10 million before he ultimately sold the franchise. But it also doesnt make the practice appropriate or fair to both sides of a legal fight. Bidwill purportedly told Minegar a portion of his letter was used in the filing; he also asked whether the team could use snippets of a September 2022 email, which Minegar sent to Bidwill congratulating the team for honoring McDonough's father, famed Boston Globe reporter Will McDonough. Jeffrey Mishkin, the former chief legal officer for the NBA, will "serve as the hearing officer" in the dispute, according to an email sent by the NFL's general counsel Jeff Pash and reviewed by ESPN. He cant win! Thats his prerogative. The vast majority probably are simply reliant on who they hire. "If an arbitration process results, we will welcome the opportunity to set the record straight in that forum and demonstrate how these claims have absolutely no validity or hard basis. ProFootballTalk on Tuesday released portions of a letter by former Cardinals COO Ron Minegar, corroborating portions of McDonough's claims against Bidwill. "Our position was consistent with many efforts we've made to accommodate Terry during his time with the team, despite difficulties in his personal life and his often volatile demeanor toward colleagues," the statement from McCarthy said. Good owners can elevate one. ", The grievance said that Wilks recently joined the racial discrimination class action lawsuit brought by former head coach Brian Flores against the NFL and its teams, with Wilks alleging that he was hired by Bidwill only to serve as a "bridge coach" without being given the opportunity to succeed and that he was "the fall guy for failures that were largely attributable to Keim.". McDonough also accused Bidwill of sabotaging Wilks' first opportunity as an NFL head coach before he fired him at the end of his one season on the job. You create your own narrative. McDonough indicated to Franz during the text messages that Franz was free to quote the entire conversation and on Monday, Franz ran with it via his broadcast partner, WTSMTV. https://t.co/GTCUT9xdSK, Cardinals official response to the Terry McDonough grievance is filed, and then leaked https://t.co/zevP6knhRA, Terry McDonough accuses Cardinals owner Michael Bidwill of cheating | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC, Adam Schefter: Ex-Cardinals VP Terry McDonough accuses owner of cheating | NFL Live, Arizona Cardinals response to Terry McDonough shows dysfunction | Pro Football Talk | NFL on NBC, Adam Schefter BREAKING: Ex-Cardinals VP Terry McDonough accuses owner Michael Bidwill of cheating, Report: 49ers Interview Terry McDonough, Cardinals VP or Player Personnel, Cardinals owner accused of cheating by former team executive, report, For people and planet: Remembering Terry McDonough. When Bidwill learned about it, he ordered the phones to be collected and told the executive the disposable phone idea was misguided and inconsistent with terms of Keim's suspension. Sign up for the For The Win newsletter to get our top stories in your inbox every morning. After 17 NFL seasons, including 16 in Green Bay, three-time MVP and one-time Super Bowl champion Favre was traded . Interesting how many commenters dont see the difference between an employee (or former employee) disclosing wrongdoing by the employer and the employer making PERSONAL ATTACKS against the former employee. How will the NFL handle the accusations against Michael Bidwill? Former Cardinals executive Terry McDonough has filed an arbitration claim with the NFL regarding his former team. If accusations are incorrect or outright false then speak up. occurred shortly after McDonough's text to Bidwill regarding the Keim recordings. Wilks has declined ESPN's request for comment. Once the Cardinals VP of player personnel, McDonough is listed on the Cardinals website as a senior personnel executive. I guess it would be good to wait and see how things unfold before making too many judgments one way or the other. Terry McDonough salary income and net worth data provided by People Ai provides an estimation for any internet celebrity's real salary income and net worth like Terry McDonough based on real numbers. McDonough maintained that both he and former Cardinals head coach Steve Wilks were left with no choice but to follow Bidwill's plan to use burner phones to communicate with former Arizona general manager Steve Keim while Keim was serving a five-week suspension after pleading guilty to extreme DUI in Arizona. McDonough has been in the NFL since interning with the 49ers in 1989. Sometimes, there's a comment in response. The filing claimed Bidwill at one point made the women one five months pregnant, the other seven months cry as a result of "abusive and bullying mistreatment. So bush league. Here's everything you need to know about McDonough's accusations against the Cardinals from cheating to harassment and discrimination as well as the responses by the NFL, Arizona and Minegar. But in the correct way. As for Terry McDonough, he can file a defamation lawsuit against the Cardinals if anything they say isnt true. ", The grievance said: "The passage of time and exposure of the facts have revealed those comments to be almost perverse in their inaccuracy, misguidedness, and gaslighting nature. . According to ESPNs Tisha Thompson, the league has selected former chief legal officer of the NBA Jeffrey Mishkin to serve as the hearing officer. Aside from his demotion, McDonough accused Bidwill of blocking him from other opportunities around the NFL, alleging that opportunities for other jobs across the league disappeared. Chargers never win either. I also requested that my entire resignation letter be used instead of just one page to provide proper context. Texans throw first curveball of draft with Stroud, Eagles are stacked after drafting Carter, Smith, Witherspoon is organic fit for Seahawks culture, Texans pull off back-to-back move to get Anderson, Lions taking Gibbs was headscratcher of Round 1, NFL appoints arbitrator for Terry McDonoughs claims against the Cardinals, In the end, the Packers fleeced the Jets for Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Rodgers blamed cell service at his house for not returning Brian Gutekunsts calls, Trade charts show Jets sending Packers equivalent of a high second-round pick in 2023, Odds greatly improve for Will Levis to be the first overall pick, Brian Gutekunst: It would have been nice to have had those conversations with Aaron Rodgers, Jim Irsay asks fans whether Colts should pair Will Levis with Anthony Richardson, Jalen Carter says Eagles will take him at No. dryzzt23 says: See round-by-round results and grades for each pick at the USA TODAY Sports NFL Draft Hub. Isnt cheating supposed to help you win? https://cardswire.usatoday.com/2023/04/25/nfl-appoints-former-nba-lawyer-to-arbitrate-terry-mcdonough-michael-bidwill-conflict/, Bills, Chiefs could still be in play for DeAndre Hopkins trade. 10, if hes there. The Sunday Ticket component affects the revenue projection, thus holding up cap finality. McDonough's arbitration claim accuses the Cardinals of breach of contract, retaliation after engaging in protected activity, intentional infliction of emotional distress, defamation, and civil conspiracy. In 2017, he was a finalist for the San Francisco 49ers' general manager position, along with John Lynch and George Paton, the current general managers of the 49ers and Denver Broncos. Having the CEO settle all claims is beyond absurd and shouldnt be tolerated. My question here, of course, is how much of the Cardinals dysfunction is on the Bidwells and how much is on Keim. The demotion occurred in 2019, according to Stewart Mandel, Kalyn Kahler and Mike Sando of The Athletic (subscription required). One thing the players union must do is die on their collective swords to get the Goodell settles arbitration cases clause out of the CBA and they should require it to be removed from all league employees. He leads the sports practice atSkadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom. It's actually a myth about how to make money on Facebook Terry McDonough is a British television director. The idea was that the Cardinals could hide their apparent cheating conduct under the table by using these phones. The Cardinals have 20 days to respond to McDonough's claims under the NFL's dispute resolution procedural guidelines. Landing spots for top undrafted free agents: Who signed after Round 7? The efforts may be disgusting, but they are probably affective and most likely true. ", How will the NFL handle the accusations against Michael Bidwill? The organization did concede that an unnamed executive "interfered with the protocol of (Keim's) suspension," but that Bidwill took "swift action" once said interference was discovered. They hired competent counsel who worked quietly to build an effective defense. The way the Cardinals have tried to smear him is disgusting. April 5, 2023 at 1:50 pm That changed when we got the first round of results from the employee engagement study. It looks like McDonough might have been the brains behind the teams success in the Keim era. The press is trying to paint Mike B into a corner. That doesnt make him a liar, and it certainly doesnt mean he deserves to be ostracized and doubted before getting to plead his side. The Cards suspended Keim after his extreme DUI arrest that year. No horse in this race. Bidwill also subjected McDonough to bullying, mocking, harassing and abusive behavior.". Team attorneys say the "burner phones" were distributed shortly after Keim's team-imposed suspension by a senior football executive who is no longer with the organization. Yea, not well. gibson45 says: Updated 2021 NFL salary cap rankings for all 32 teams after Super Bowl. It looks like it might be worse. Register now! Some think every claim made against owners is a money grab, as though the NFL owners are paragons of virtue. McDonough is still in possession of the burner phone, according to his claim, which includes a picture of the device. In his grievance claim to the NFL, McDonough, the teams former vice president of player personnel, accuses Bidwill of gross misconduct, including cheating, discrimination and harassment. . In McDonoughs filing, first reported on Tuesday by ESPN, the former scout said he and Wilks objected to and sought to avoid participation in a scheme hatched by Bidwill to utilize burner phones to communicate with general manager Steve Keim in violation of the terms of Keims suspension for extreme DUI during a critical period of the Cardinals training camp in the summer of 2018, the arbitration claim states. NFL mock draft database 2016 - 49ers picks across the Internet 2016 NFL calendar: League year, free agency, draft, salary cap deadlines 49ers The Cardinals have been a lousy organization for a long, long time. Then Goodell "shall determine whether the dispute is football-oriented or not football-oriented" and whether the dispute is subject to arbitration. (2:11). FOR YEARS!!! The owner is purported to have created a workplace culture centered around fear among his employees, and that he even went so far as to cancel a 2019 employee engagement survey that indicated changes were needed. Well really now. Often, a company accused of misconduct by a former employee has no comment in response. This allegation would also align with a recent revelation from the NFLPA that the Cardinals do not provide their players with sufficient support and amenities. The fish rots from the head. We look forward to the truth coming out at arbitration.. In 2022, McDonough said he was demoted again from seventh to ninth in command. Yes. The demotion cut McDonoughs salary from $550K to $330K. Information from The Associated Press was used in this report. Lawyer: Cardinals effort to smear Terry McDonough is disgusting. Not a member? In patton state hospital rn salary. He said other opportunities in the NFL "evaporated" after he elected not to go along with Bidwill's attempt to cheat. didnt he throw out ownerships dirty laundryreep what you sow. No horse in this race. Cardinals fan and living the drama every year. April 5, 2023 at 1:27 pm The Cardinals have 20 days to respond to McDonough's claims under the NFL's dispute resolution procedural guidelines. He wants to be reinstated to his position? McDonough's . The press is merely reporting the available information, McDonoughs initial filing, Bidwills public relations response, and McDonoughs attorneys reaction to that response. Per ESPN, McDonough has accused Bidwill in an arbitration claim filed to NFL commissioner Roger Goodell of gross misconduct, which includes cheating, discrimination . McDonough sent the arbitration claim to the league April 4. It is not a smear to expose the truth about an organizations wrongdoing and fraudulent activities. McDonough needs to use any available angle to take this case to civil court, secret, rigged kangaroo court label that we sometimes use. Thats why I suddenly disappeared. Instead of leaning into it and trying to change things for the better, you shut the study down. "We are reluctantly obliged to provide a public response along with broader context for some disappointing and irresponsible actions by Terry McDonough," external public relations adviser to the Cardinals Jim McCarthy said in a statement. The Cardinals and Bidwill filed their legal response on Monday in which they cited several instances of what they described as McDonough's "erratic behavior" that they claim "eventually damaged his career," according to the Associated Press. The NFL's minimum salary in 2021 is $660,000.According to UPI, Bradshaw was the second-highest paid quarterback in NFL history with a $470,000 contract in 1981. I really do. redlikethepig says: In the claim, McDonough said that opportunities for advancement in the NFL evaporated after his refusal to go along with Bidwill. Under league rules, the Cardinals have 20 days to respond to McDonoughs filing. McDonough's. Arbitration clauses can be broken if rules arent fully followed. The NFL has selected the NBA's former top lawyer to arbitrate an employment dispute between Arizona Cardinals owner Michael Bidwill and the team's former vice president of player personnel, Terry McDonough. April 10, 2023 7:22 am MT. McDonough is seeking damages for breach of contract and emotional distress. All rights reserved. That is expected to take several months. He accused team owner Michael Bidwill of cheating, harassment, discrimination and misconduct. Terry sounds like a terrible person. But that doesnt mean there is merit to McDonoughs complaint. Former Cardinals vice president Terry McDonough is accusing team owner Michael Bidwill of gross misconduct, including cheating, discrimination and harassment, in an arbitration claim. Please login to leave a reply. . How did being quiet work out for the Duke Lacrosse team? Jets' Aaron Rodgers expects a 'heaven' and 'hell' relationship with Zach Wilson, Top picks Christian Gonzalez, Keion White reflect Patriots' ideal identity, Big takeaways from the NFL draft: A historic QB class, the rebuilt AFC South and new GMs thriving, XFL semifinals: Defenders roll Sea Dragons, set up title showdown with Renegades, Bijan Robinson shares that this is his second stint with the Falcons. April 5, 2023 at 1:41 pm The Cardinals should just defend themselves against the claims. Heres what we know so far about the allegations. Former NBA lawyer to arbitrate Cardinals dispute, LB Barrett's 2-year-old daughter drowns in pool, Deion 'ashamed' after only 1 HBCU player drafted, Sources: NFL eyes May 11 to release schedule, Teams set NFL record with 43 trades during draft, Jets coach Saleh: Rodgers making 'presence felt', Cowboys scout emotional as team drafts his son, Rams use 'Mr. Irrelevant' pick on Toledo's Johnson, Chargers go all-in on TCU with Duggan pick in 7th, NFL Nation sizes up all 259 draft selections. Locker Room: F Weight Room: F Food Service: F Treatment of player families: F Winning record last 20 years: F Super Bowl Field: F Playoff Wins last 10 years: 0. lol, these desert clowns are perpetrating Cardinal on Cardinal crime. Problem with going scorched Earth is you frequently burn yourself in the process. I personally felt that neither Wilks nor Rosen were ever given an actual chance to develop, and that the Cardinals put significantly fewer resources into that roster than they did a year later for Murrays rebuild. Arizona Cardinals executive Terry McDonough has filed an arbitration demand with the NFL accusing team owner Michael Bidwill of demoting McDonough in 2019 after McDonough objected to a. Former Arizona Cardinals front office executive Terry McDonough, who has filed a grievance case with the NFL against team owner Michael Bidwill, is making his first public comments since the. NFL. I stand by the statements I made in my December 2019 letter and am willing to discuss with the involved parties as part of the NFLs Arbitration Process. gibson45 says: Considering how perpetually poorly run and unsuccessful the Cardinals organization has been, this behaviour seems to be on brand for them. Plus injury news, trade value, add drop advice, graphs, and more. It is not a smear to expose the truth about an organizations wrongdoing and fraudulent activities Then Goodell "shall determine whether . The people around you feel it daily and it impacts them more than you understand., MORE: Former Cardinals GM Steve Keim gives honest assessment of QB Kyler Murray: 'He still needs to grow'. Landing spots for top undrafted free agents: Who signed after Round 7? April 5, 2023 at 12:27 pm Im gonna side with the owner on this one.It sounds like a money grab to me. Weve seen leaked emails between former Washington owner Dan Snyder and Jon Gruden. Home Customizable Rankings Projections Public Betting Splits NFL DFS . McDonough claims he and Wilks were forced into participating in the scheme, and that he still has the burner phone which provides evidence of Bidwill's attempts at illicit communication. No way the Cards lawyers advised this just no way. Goodell will do nothing. The grievance also said Bidwill reduced two pregnant women -- one five months pregnant, the other seven months -- to tears after screaming at them with "abusive and bullying mistreatment.". In his claim, per the ESPN report, McDonough the younger brother of ESPN play-by-play commentator Sean McDonough alleged that he and former head coach Steve Wilks were forced to use burner phones to keep in contact with former general manager Steve Keim, who was serving a five-week suspension for a summer 2018 DUI in Arizona. Irrelevant' pick on Toledo's Johnson, Chargers go all-in on TCU with Duggan pick in 7th, NFL Nation sizes up all 259 draft selections. Sean has an average salary of $116,937 per year. Texans throw first curveball of draft with Stroud, Eagles are stacked after drafting Carter, Smith, Witherspoon is organic fit for Seahawks culture, Texans pull off back-to-back move to get Anderson, Lions taking Gibbs was headscratcher of Round 1, Lawyer: Cardinals effort to smear Terry McDonough is disgusting, In the end, the Packers fleeced the Jets for Aaron Rodgers, Aaron Rodgers blamed cell service at his house for not returning Brian Gutekunsts calls, Trade charts show Jets sending Packers equivalent of a high second-round pick in 2023, Odds greatly improve for Will Levis to be the first overall pick, Brian Gutekunst: It would have been nice to have had those conversations with Aaron Rodgers, Jim Irsay asks fans whether Colts should pair Will Levis with Anthony Richardson, Jalen Carter says Eagles will take him at No. _______________, It is not a smear to expose the truth about an organizations wrongdoing and fraudulent activities. I dont know the intimate details as to why-it always seemed from the outside that Keim just saw Murray and fell in love with and had a hair brained impulse to just blow the thing up-but it certainly seemed from the exterior that the Cardinals never gave the Wilks regime an actual chance. (2:11), Ex-Cards exec accuses owner Bidwill of cheating, LB Barrett's 2-year-old daughter drowns in pool, Deion 'ashamed' after only 1 HBCU player drafted, Sources: NFL eyes May 11 to release schedule, Teams set NFL record with 43 trades during draft, Jets coach Saleh: Rodgers making 'presence felt', Cowboys scout emotional as team drafts his son, Rams use 'Mr. And then, in a profession you had given your life to, no one gave you a chance to plead your side before accepting all the negative things that were said and simply discarding you? I also took the opportunity to apologize for my role in the deterioration of our relationship over the last several years of my employment," Minegar said. You deserve to be happy, but you are miserable. McDonough claims Bidwill treated a Black employee and two pregnant women poorly while "creating an environment of fear for minority employees." In 99% of cases, the defendant, through counsel responds, to the facts and denies the claims, primarily though the legal documents, and even more limited with press releases. Always. Jess Root. Arizona also issued a statement to PFT, claiming the contents of Minegar's 2019 letter were later retracted in 2022: The concerns you are describing from Mr. Minegar were later characterized by Mr. Minegar himself as misguided and were pulled back in a note of apology that he volunteered to our teams owner, McCarthy told PFT. He has been active since 1985. The NFL has exercised its prerogative to appoint an arbitrator. ______________. He couldnt fire me because he knew I had him dead in his tracks. You know it. He will also determine whether the dispute can be settled through arbitration. As explained yesterday, the teams lengthy statement makes personal attacks against McDonough that are gratuitous, excessive, and unbecoming. How are you already deciding which one to side with? Did Boswell actively scheme with Keim, direct him, or simply go along with what Keim influenced him to do? The Arizona Cardinals are entering a new era with a new head coach and new general manager. McDonough said Bidwill has continued to "demote and harass" him since summer 2018. McDonough is in his fourth season with the Cardinals and his third as a vice president and is widely regarded as one of the most sought after personnel men in the NFL. McDonough accused Bidwill of gross misconduct, including cheating, discrimination and harassment, in an arbitration claim sent to NFL commissioner Roger Goodell on April 4. Claims he has made in an arbitration filing as wildly false, reckless, and an opportunistic ploy for financial gain. The Ringer's NFL staff has wild predictions for Thursday night. Wilks alleged the Cardinals gave him little chance to succeed and unfairly and discriminatorily fired him at the end of the 18 season. Subscribe on Apple podcasts or Spotify. "Steve Wilks has demonstrated that he is a skilled NFL head coach when he is not forced to cheat and is given an opportunity to succeed," the claim reads. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The Cardinals have 20 days to formally respond to McDonoughs claim per the NFLs official guidelines. Why would the cardinals care if he came into the building on draft day, Keim went on benders all the time. The allegations include that both McDonough and Wilks were coerced by Bidwill into using burner phones to communicate with then-general manager Steve Keim during Keims five-week suspension in the summer of 2018 after pleading guilty to extreme DUI in Chandler. But Terry McDonough efforts to smear the Cardinals is stunning and brave. The response is remarkable in its length and detail, but I cant help but feel bad for McDonough. And it looks like he might be right. And that is ON the record, McDonough said in a text message to Doug Franz, host of the Doug Franz Unplugged podcast. While more impartial than the Commissioner would have been, Mishkins appointment puts the rigged in the secret, rigged kangaroo court label that we sometimes use to describe a process in which the referee is working a game between a team that employs him and a team that doesnt. Our position was consistent with many efforts we've made to accommodate Terry during his time with the team, despite difficulties in his personal life and his often volatile demeanor toward colleagues. PFT obtained the letter, which detailed several aspects of Minegar's dissatisfaction with Bidwill's demeanor. Not me. If they wont, the league should compel them to do so. If the allegations are proven true, they should hit the Cardinals hard with a fine and Bidwell should be barred from anything with the team for a while. The Cardinals should delete their comments about McDonough. Mishkin led the NBA's in-house legal department for seven years before becoming the head of sports practice at the law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom. Terry McDonough: a man who overcame a series of adversities including a fatal car crash that National Press Club (United States) net worth, International Bank of Azerbaijan net worth, CORRUPTION: What happened to Grant Solomon?